VXI Global Solutions, LLC operates customer service call centers nationwide. In February 2023 it hired Tracie Bennett, who has a high school education, as an account associate; she left the job in April 2023. Her new-hire packet ran roughly 100 pages and included an arbitration agreement and a separate confidentiality agreement, both signed the same day. Bennett did not consult a lawyer, though Global’s corporate counsel testified she had the opportunity to review the packet during orientation.
The arbitration agreement, drafted by Global and written in the employee’s voice, required arbitration of all individual claims involving the “Company” and its past or present partners, officers, employees or agents, “whether or not those claims or controversies arise out of my employment.” It defined “Company” broadly to reach partners, officers, directors, employees, affiliates, benefit plans and successors. It survived termination of employment, could be modified or revoked only by a writing signed by all of Global’s partners and the employee, and contained a severability clause. The companion confidentiality agreement barred Bennett from soliciting Global employees for a competing business during her employment and for one year afterward, and entitled Global to injunctive relief without proof of actual damages and without prior actual notice.
In October 2023, Bennett filed a putative class action in Los Angeles County Superior Court alleging 10 causes of action, including unpaid minimum wages and overtime and missed meal and rest breaks. Global moved to compel arbitration.
Judge David S. Cunningham III held that the Federal Arbitration Act (9 U.S.C. § 1 et seq.) governed the agreement and found a low degree of procedural unconscionability because it was a contract of adhesion. Relying on Cook v. University of Southern California (2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 312, the court found substantive unconscionability in two respects: the agreement reached claims unrelated to employment, and its duration was unreasonable because it outlived the job and could be ended only by mutual agreement. The court rejected Bennett’s other arguments, including challenges to the attorney fee terms, the waiver of public injunctive relief, and the handling of PAGA representative claims, and it did not reach her attacks on the confidentiality agreement. Concluding the defects could not be severed without rewriting the contract, the court denied the motion. Global appealed, as an order denying arbitration is immediately appealable under Code of Civil Procedure § 1294, subdivision (a).
In the published case of Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, LLC, No. B346763 (November 2026), the California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Eight, affirmed the trial court’s order denying the employer’s motion to compel arbitration and awarded Bennett her costs on appeal. The opinion, filed November 13, 2026, is certified for publication. Justice Viramontes wrote for the majority, with Presiding Justice Stratton concurring; Justice Wiley filed an extensive dissent.
The majority first held that, under Civil Code § 1642, the arbitration and confidentiality agreements must be read together as a single contract, because they were signed in the same transaction and address related subject matter. Unfair terms in the confidentiality agreement therefore count against the arbitration agreement. On procedural unconscionability, the court agreed the degree was low. Global did not dispute that the agreement was adhesive, but there was no evidence of pressure or a rushed signing, Bennett had a reasonable chance to review the documents and consult counsel, and the language, while sometimes lengthy, was not unduly complex. Her education level and unfamiliarity with arbitration did not show she could not understand the terms.
Substantive unconscionability, however, was high. Read as a whole, the agreement would force Bennett to arbitrate nearly any claim involving Global, related to her job or not, for the rest of her life unless both sides agreed otherwise. The court rejected Global’s narrower reading because it would render the “whether or not” language meaningless. The expansive definition of “Company” made a large group of employees, officers, agents and affiliates third-party beneficiaries who could compel Bennett to arbitrate, while she had no reciprocal right to force their claims against her into arbitration, a one-sided arrangement Global did not justify. The injunctive relief clause let Global obtain injunctions without proving the usual elements, including irreparable harm. And the nonsolicitation clause, which was not limited to unlawful means of solicitation, was void under Business and Professions Code § 16600.
Turning to remedy, the court explained that Civil Code § 1670.5, subdivision (a), lets a court refuse enforcement, sever an offending term, or limit it, but not rewrite the parties’ bargain. Because the agreement contained multiple unconscionable terms and its overbroad scope went to its central purpose, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in declining to sever. Global’s proposed fix of striking two phrases would not work, the majority said, because the remaining text would still cover all claims involving Global, and adding limiting language would amount to rewriting the contract. Striking the confidentiality agreement’s injunctive and nonsolicitation terms would not cure the arbitration agreement’s own defects.
Finally, the majority rejected the dissent’s position that the FAA preempts California’s unconscionability analysis here. It relied on Sonic-Calabasas A, Inc. v. Moreno (2013) 57 Cal.4th 1109, OTO, L.L.C. v. Kho (2019) 8 Cal.5th 111, Ramirez v. Charter Communications, Inc. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 478, and Ninth Circuit decisions applying California law. It distinguished U.S. Supreme Court rulings such as AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion (2011) 563 U.S. 333 as striking down rules that barred arbitration outright or imposed procedures at odds with its basic features. Unconscionability findings arise more often in adhesive contracts, the majority reasoned, and such contracts frequently contain arbitration clauses, so arbitration is not being singled out.
Overbroad Arbitration Clause Trimmed and Case Sent to Arbitration
CN Motor Company LLC, doing business as Santa Monica Lincoln, is an automobile dealership. Luis Antonio Salazar filled out an employment application on June 6,
There are 0 comments